Holiday sale: 20% off our printables on Etsy, Nov 16 to Dec 2. Shop the sale

Social skills · Kids, school counselors, SLPs and special education · Updated 2026-11-12

Expected vs unexpected behavior: how to teach it without turning it into a behavior chart (free worksheet)

Social skills group: Social Skills Small Group Curriculum, Grades 2 to 5, 8 sessions with lesson plans and student pages Holiday 20% off: about $11.04, was $14 (EUR 12) · instant digital download

Buy on Etsy

Ages 5 to 11: Kids Feelings and Social Skills Worksheets, incl. naming feelings, body signals and calming down Holiday 20% off: about $11.04, was $14 (EUR 12) · fillable PDF, instant digital download

Buy on Etsy

Try it free first: download a fillable sample (feelings thermometer and calm-down plan, PDF, 240 KB). Type into it on screen, then get the full pack. No email needed.

Visual supports: Visual Schedule and Behavior Supports, 23 pages with token boards, a reward menu, first then boards and 136 picture cards Holiday 20% off: about $6.44, was $8 (EUR 7) · instant digital download

Buy on Etsy

"Expected" and "unexpected" are some of the most used words in elementary social skills teaching, and some of the most misused. The idea is simple and genuinely useful: whether an action fits depends on the situation. Shouting is expected at a soccer game and unexpected in a library. The problem starts when the words become a polite replacement for "good" and "bad", and "that's unexpected" turns into a scolding.

This guide is for school counselors, speech-language pathologists, special education teachers, classroom teachers and parents. It covers where the vocabulary comes from, what it is meant to teach, what the research does and does not show, the fair criticism from autistic adults, 9 teaching steps, activities, examples by age and common mistakes. It ends with a free 2 page printable: an It Depends on the Situation sorting worksheet and a Read the Situation Plan with a 5 day tracker.

Download the free expected vs unexpected behavior worksheet (PDF, 2 pages, US Letter)
Direct download, no email or sign up. See the pages first.

Where "expected and unexpected" comes from

The terms come from the Social Thinking Methodology developed by speech-language pathologist Michelle Garcia Winner, where they are part of a larger set of teaching vocabulary. Social Thinking is a registered trademark of its owners; Lotus & Tulip is not affiliated with them, and this page and the free printable are our own original take on the general idea.

Winner has written plainly about how the words are meant to be used. In her article "It's Not About Appropriate vs. Inappropriate!", she explains that many adults have taken the vocabulary and used it "to scold, redirect, or reward a behavior" instead of teaching the reasons behind social expectations. Her key point is that "it's not the behavior that is expected or unexpected, it's the situation that dictates whether it is." She gives the example of a birthday party piñata: in a classroom, teachers and students act differently, but around a piñata both are likely laughing, yelling and swinging a stick.

The same article recommends teaching students to observe three things about a situation: where we are, who the people are, and what is happening. It also advises spending much more time noticing when students figure out what is expected than pointing out what is unexpected.

What expected and unexpected actually mean

The same actionUsually expected hereUsually unexpected here
Talking in a loud voiceOn the playground, cheering at a gameIn the library, during a test
Running fastIn a race at recessIn a crowded hallway
Asking a questionDuring a lesson, when you are confusedWhile a friend is crying about something else
Telling a jokeAt lunch with friendsDuring a fire drill
HuggingYour parent at pickup, if you both like hugsA new kid you just met
Saying "I disagree"In a class debateAbout a friend's drawing they are proud of

What the research shows (and does not)

The best known study is a small one. Crooke, Hendrix and Rachman (2008) taught a Social Thinking based group to six boys with Asperger syndrome or high functioning autism (the terms used at the time) for eight weekly 60 minute sessions. The approach explained the "why" behind social behavior and, unlike many earlier programs, did not use rewards or punishments. The boys showed significant pre to post increases in "expected" verbal behavior, "listening/thinking with eyes" and initiations, and decreases in "unexpected" behaviors overall.

An honest caveat: that study had six participants, no control group and was led by researchers connected to the approach. We found no large controlled trials of teaching the expected and unexpected vocabulary by itself. It is best seen as a clear way to talk about social situations, not a proven stand alone intervention. The study is also a reminder that its "expected" behaviors (like "thinking with eyes") reflect typical social norms, which leads to the criticism below.

The fair criticism, and how to teach it better

Many autistic adults and neurodiversity affirming clinicians have criticized how the vocabulary is used in practice. The main points are worth taking seriously:

Social Thinking's own materials now stress the same direction: the vocabulary is meant to build social understanding and choice, not obedience. So in practice, teach it like this:

How to teach expected vs unexpected behavior, step by step

  1. Start with surprise, not rules. Ask: "Has anyone ever done something that really surprised you? How did you feel?" This frames unexpected as "not what people thought would happen", including happy surprises.
  2. Teach the three situation clues. Where am I, who is here, and what is happening? Practice naming them for familiar places: the lunchroom, a birthday party, the bus, a doctor's waiting room.
  3. Show that the same action changes. Pick one action (talking loudly, running, singing) and sort it across two situations. The first page of the free worksheet does exactly this with eight actions.
  4. Connect actions to feelings. Ask how people in the situation might feel and think. Expected actions usually help people feel calm; unexpected ones might cause surprise, confusion or worry. Keep it about people's reactions, not about being good or bad.
  5. Find the hidden rules. Ask: "What is something everyone here seems to know, but nobody says?" Write the class's hidden rules for one place together.
  6. Practice being a detective. Teach ways to figure out what is expected when you are not sure: watch what others are doing, look for a sign or a schedule, wait and listen first, or simply ask, "What do we do here?"
  7. Notice expected choices far more than unexpected ones. Say it specifically and warmly: "You noticed everyone was whispering in the library and you whispered too." If you must talk about an unexpected moment, do it calmly and later, not in front of peers.
  8. Plan for one tricky situation. With the child, choose one real situation that is hard for them (an assembly, a group project, a family dinner) and fill in the Read the Situation Plan: what people expect, what is hard, what they will try, and what support helps.
  9. Track, review and adjust. Use the 5 day tracker for a week. Review it together, celebrate what worked and change the plan, or the situation, if something keeps being hard.

Expected vs unexpected activities

Examples by age

Common mistakes

Free expected vs unexpected behavior worksheet

This free printable is an original Lotus & Tulip layout on US Letter. Page 1, It Depends on the Situation, teaches the three situation clues (where, who, what), has eight actions to sort as expected or unexpected in two different situations, and asks how people might feel and for the child's own example and a hidden rule they noticed. Page 2, My Read the Situation Plan, plans for one tricky situation, lists ways to figure out what is expected, adds a 5 day tracker and a guide for adults.

Free printable expected vs unexpected behavior worksheet page 1: read the situation clues where, who and what, eight actions to sort as expected or unexpected in two situations, and how people might feel

Free printable read the situation plan: a plan for one tricky situation, ways to figure out what is expected, a 5 day tracker and a guide for adults

Download the free expected vs unexpected behavior worksheet (PDF, 2 pages, US Letter)

Prefer single images? Page 1: it depends on the situation (PNG) · Page 2: my read the situation plan (PNG)

Free to print for use with your own students, clients or children. Please link to this page rather than re-uploading the file. A social understanding teaching tool, not a behavior rating or an assessment.

Teaching this in a social skills group? The Social Skills Small Group Curriculum (now about $11.04 on Etsy, was $14) gives you eight ready to teach sessions for grades 2 to 5. For individual practice, the Kids Feelings and Social Skills Worksheets (now about $11.04, was $14) cover feelings, body signals and calming down, and the Visual Schedule and Behavior Supports (now about $6.44, was $8) add picture cards and first then boards that make expectations visible before a tricky situation.

Related resources

FAQ

What is the difference between expected and unexpected behavior?

An expected behavior is what most people in a situation are thinking will happen, so it tends to leave them feeling calm or comfortable. An unexpected behavior is something people in that situation were not thinking would happen, so it can surprise or confuse them. The same action can be expected in one situation and unexpected in another.

Who came up with expected and unexpected behaviors?

The terms are part of the Social Thinking Methodology developed by speech-language pathologist Michelle Garcia Winner. Social Thinking is a trademark of its owners; this page is not affiliated with them.

Is expected vs unexpected the same as appropriate vs inappropriate?

It is not supposed to be. Winner has written that the vocabulary was designed to teach why social expectations exist in a given situation, not to scold or redirect. When it is used only to correct children, it works the same way as "inappropriate" and loses its point.

Is teaching expected and unexpected behavior harmful for autistic kids?

It can be when it is used to push compliance or to hide harmless autistic traits such as stimming or looking away, which can encourage masking. Taught as useful information about situations, with respect for the child's way of being and with adults adjusting too, it can help a child understand and choose, not just obey.

What age is this worksheet for?

The sorting worksheet works best for about ages 5 to 11, kindergarten through grade 5. Older students can use the plan page and talk about "reading the room" in more grown up situations like group chats and team sports.

Is this expected vs unexpected behavior worksheet free?

Yes. It is free to print for use with your own students, clients or children. Please link to this page rather than re-uploading the file.

Sources

Social Skills Small Group Curriculum for School Counselors, Grades 2 to 5Holiday 20% off: about $11.04, was $14 (EUR 12)
Buy on Etsy