Holiday sale: 20% off our printables on Etsy, Nov 16 to Dec 2. Shop the sale

Therapist worksheets · Motivation and change · Updated 2026-11-05

Decisional Balance Worksheet: Pros and Cons of Change, How to Use It Well, and a Free Printable

Ready-made printable: Relapse Prevention Worksheets Holiday 20% off: about $9.20, was $12 (EUR 10) · instant digital download

Buy on Etsy
Title card: decisional balance worksheet, weigh the pros and cons of change, free 3 page printable
Decisional balance worksheet, weigh the pros and cons of change, free 3 page printable.

A decisional balance worksheet asks a person to look at a possible change from four sides: what is good about how things are now, what is not so good about how things are now, what might be hard about changing, and what might be good about changing. It is one of the most common handouts in substance use treatment, health coaching, school counseling and general therapy, and it shows up in almost every stages of change workbook.

It is also one of the most misunderstood. The research behind motivational interviewing (MI) suggests that a full, evenly weighted pros and cons exercise can actually lower commitment to change in someone who is still on the fence. Used at the right moment and in the right way, the same four boxes are a calm, respectful way to think a decision through. This guide covers where the tool came from, when it helps, when to choose something else, how to run it with teens and adults, the DBT version for urges, common mistakes, and what the evidence honestly says. You also get a free three page US Letter printable.

This page is educational. It is not a substitute for assessment or treatment by a licensed clinician, especially for substance use, eating disorders, or anything involving safety.

Jump to the free decisional balance worksheet (PDF) · How to use it, step by step · The MI caution every clinician should know

What a decisional balance is

A decisional balance is a structured way of listing the expected gains and losses of a choice. In counseling the choice is usually a behavior change: drinking less, quitting vaping, starting medication, going back to school, leaving a job, ending a relationship, using a coping skill instead of an old habit.

The classic worksheet is a two by two grid:

Some versions collapse this to two columns, "pros of changing" and "cons of changing." The four box version is more complete because the cost of staying the same is not always just the mirror image of the benefit of changing. A teen who vapes may list "my friends all do it" as a good thing about now and "I would feel left out at lunch" as a cost of changing. Those are related, but writing both makes the social pull visible.

Where it came from

The idea of writing down reasons on each side of a choice is old. In a 1772 letter to the chemist Joseph Priestley, Benjamin Franklin described dividing a sheet of paper into two columns, listing pros and cons over several days, and crossing out reasons of roughly equal weight. He called it "moral or prudential algebra."

The modern clinical version comes from psychologists Irving Janis and Leon Mann. In their 1977 book Decision Making: A Psychological Analysis of Conflict, Choice, and Commitment, they proposed a "decisional balance sheet" with four categories of anticipated consequences: practical gains and losses for oneself, practical gains and losses for important others, self approval or disapproval, and approval or disapproval from others. Their concern was how people make important decisions under stress, and how to help them avoid snap choices or defensive avoidance.

James Prochaska, Carlo DiClemente and colleagues then built decisional balance into the transtheoretical model, better known as the stages of change. When Velicer and colleagues (1985) tested a decisional balance questionnaire for smoking, the eight Janis and Mann categories collapsed statistically into just two factors: the pros and the cons of the behavior. That simpler two factor structure is what most worksheets still use.

Decisional balance and the stages of change

The stages of change describe readiness as a process rather than a yes or no switch. The commonly used stages are:

Prochaska and colleagues (1994) looked at decisional balance across 12 problem behaviors, including smoking, cocaine use, weight control, condom use, sunscreen use, exercise and mammography screening, in 3,858 participants. A fairly consistent pattern appeared: in precontemplation the cons of changing outweigh the pros, the pros rise as people move into contemplation, and the two lines usually cross before action. A companion paper described "strong and weak principles" of change: moving from precontemplation to action was linked with roughly a one standard deviation increase in perceived pros and about half a standard deviation decrease in perceived cons. A later meta-analysis by Hall and Rossi (2008) across 48 health behaviors found a broadly similar pattern.

The practical takeaway is that the balance of pros to cons is a reasonable marker of readiness. It does not automatically follow that asking someone to list every pro and con will move them toward change. That distinction is the heart of the next section.

A fair caveat: the stages of change model is influential but debated. Critics such as West (2005) argue the stage boundaries are arbitrary and that stage matched interventions have not consistently outperformed unmatched ones. Many clinicians still find the stages a useful, informal way to think about readiness, as long as they are not treated as rigid boxes.

The motivational interviewing caution

Early descriptions of motivational interviewing encouraged clinicians to "explore ambivalence," and decisional balance exercises were often used to do that. As MI matured, William Miller and Stephen Rollnick drew a clearer line between two different ways of responding to ambivalence:

In a 2015 review in Behavioural and Cognitive Psychotherapy, Miller and Gary Rose summarized the clinical research this way: with people who are ambivalent, a decisional balance intervention tends to decrease commitment to change, while MI style evocation tends to promote it. When someone has already decided to change, the picture flips: evocation is unnecessary, and a decisional balance may further strengthen commitment. Their recommendation was that clinicians using MI to help an ambivalent person move toward change should not include a decisional balance as part of the intervention.

Why would listing the cons of change backfire? People tend to believe what they hear themselves say. If a session spends twenty minutes carefully building the case for drinking, vaping or skipping medication, the person leaves having rehearsed that case out loud. MI research links more change talk in sessions with better outcomes, and more sustain talk with worse ones. Mindset research by Peter Gollwitzer points the same way: deliberating every pro and con suits a person who is genuinely choosing, not one who is trying to build momentum.

So when is a decisional balance the right tool?

When to choose something else

If the person is ambivalent and your goal, agreed with them, is to help them move toward a healthier change, MI suggests skipping the full four box exercise and using evocation instead: open questions about their own reasons, importance and confidence rulers, looking forward and looking back, and exploring values. Page 3 of the free printable, My Reasons and Next Step, is built around that approach.

How to use a decisional balance worksheet, step by step

  1. Decide your stance first. Ask yourself whether you are counseling with neutrality (a personal decision with no right answer) or helping someone toward a change they have said they want. Use the full grid for the first, and for people who have already decided. For ambivalent people and a change goal, lean on evocation and the reasons page instead.
  2. Ask permission and name the purpose. "Would it be okay if we looked at this from a few different angles? There are no wrong answers here." People engage more when they choose to.
  3. Define the change in one concrete sentence. "Cut down to two drinks on weekend nights" works better than "drink less." "Switch to the evening shift" is clearer than "fix my job." Write it in the top box.
  4. Start with what is good about how things are now. This feels counterintuitive, but naming the real benefits of the current pattern shows respect and lowers defensiveness. Then move to what is not so good about now. Reflect what you hear rather than arguing.
  5. Fill the changing side in the person's own words. Write their phrases, not your summary. "I would be less tired at work" carries more weight than "health benefits."
  6. Weigh, do not just count. One reason can outweigh five. Ask the person to circle the two or three items that matter most, or rate each from 1 to 5. Janis and Mann's categories can help here: how does this affect me practically, the people I care about, how I see myself, and how others see me?
  7. Use the rulers. On a 0 to 10 scale, how important is this change right now, and how confident are you that you could do it if you decided to? Then ask, "Why a 5 and not a 2?" The answer is usually change talk. "What would it take to move up one point?" points toward next steps.
  8. Summarize and ask, do not tell. Offer a short summary that ends with the person's most important reasons, then ask an open question: "So where does this leave you?" Accept the answer, including "I am not ready."
  9. If they decide to change, plan one small step. Move to a concrete plan: first step, when and where, likely obstacles, supports, and a date to review. If they are not ready, agree to revisit the topic and leave the door open.
Need stages of change pages ready to print? The relapse prevention worksheets (now about $9.20 on Etsy, was $12) include a stages of change check in, a decisional balance page, my reasons for change, trigger maps and a coping skills menu. For broader caseloads, the CBT worksheets for therapists (now about $11.04, was $14) cover thought records, behavioral experiments and goal setting.

A worked example (fictional)

Maya, 34, has been drinking four to five glasses of wine most evenings since a stressful promotion. She has already told her counselor that she wants to cut back and asks for help making a plan. Because she has decided, a full decisional balance can reinforce her choice.

Maya rates "being the parent I want to be" and "the liver numbers" as the heaviest items. Importance is 8 out of 10, confidence 5. Asked why 5 and not 2, she says she managed a dry January two years ago. Her first step: alcohol free Monday through Thursday for two weeks, a walk with her partner at 7 pm instead, and a check in with her doctor about safe reduction. She keeps the sheet on her phone to reread on hard evenings.

Had Maya instead arrived unsure whether her drinking was a problem at all, an MI informed counselor would likely skip the full grid, ask about what she has noticed, reflect any concerns she raises, and explore what matters to her, rather than inviting her to build a detailed case for the evening wine.

The DBT version: pros and cons for urges

Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), developed by Marsha Linehan, includes a skill simply called Pros and Cons. It sits in the distress tolerance module as one of the crisis survival skills, alongside STOP, TIPP, distract and self-soothe. It is designed for moments when a strong urge (to self harm, use substances, binge, rage, quit impulsively) collides with what the person wants for their life.

The DBT layout is also four boxes, but framed around an urge rather than a long term change:

Key differences from the MI style decisional balance:

Page 2 of the free printable, Pros and Cons for an Urge, follows this structure with short and long term prompts and a space for the skill to use instead. For more crisis tools, see our distress tolerance worksheets, DBT TIPP skills worksheet and behavior chain analysis worksheet.

Using a decisional balance with teens

Adolescents are especially sensitive to feeling lectured, which makes the MI caution even more important. Some practical adjustments:

Our peer pressure worksheets for teens and goal setting worksheet for students pair well with the reasons page.

Using it with adults

Therapist tips

Common mistakes

What the research says (honestly)

When to get extra help

Reach out to a licensed clinician if the decision involves substance use that may require medical withdrawal management, an eating disorder, self harm, thoughts of suicide, or a relationship where safety is a concern. A worksheet can support clear thinking. It should never replace care.

Free decisional balance worksheet (PDF)

The free decisional balance worksheet has three pages in US Letter size, written for teens and adults:

Free decisional balance worksheet: four box grid of pros and cons of changing and staying the same, with importance and confidence rulers

Download the free decisional balance worksheet (PDF, 3 pages, US Letter)

Prefer single images? Page 1: Decisional Balance Grid (PNG) · Page 2: Pros and Cons for an Urge (PNG) · Page 3: My Reasons and Next Step (PNG)

Free to print for your own use and for use with your own clients, students, or groups. This is an original layout by Lotus & Tulip, not an official MI or DBT form, and not affiliated with the authors cited. Please link to this page rather than re-uploading the file.

Building a fuller motivation and relapse prevention toolkit? Start with the relapse prevention worksheets (now about $9.20 on Etsy, was $12) and the CBT worksheets for therapists (now about $11.04, was $14). For urges and crisis skills, the DBT worksheets for therapists (now about $11.04, was $14) and DBT worksheets for teens (now about $11.04, was $14) include pros and cons and distress tolerance pages. To connect change with what matters, try the ACT worksheets for therapists (now about $9.20, was $12), and for low motivation linked to mood, the depression and behavioral activation worksheets (now about $9.20, was $12).

Related resources

Sources

Decisional balance worksheet: FAQ

What is a decisional balance worksheet?

A decisional balance worksheet is a pros and cons tool that looks at a possible change from four sides: good and not so good things about how things are now, and good and not so good things about changing. It comes from Janis and Mann's 1977 decision making model and is widely used with the stages of change.

Is decisional balance part of motivational interviewing?

It used to be commonly paired with MI, but Miller and Rose (2015) concluded that a full decisional balance tends to lower commitment in ambivalent people when the goal is change. MI now favors evoking the person's own reasons for change. Decisional balance fits best when a counselor wants to stay neutral or when the person has already decided.

What are the four quadrants of a decisional balance?

The four quadrants are the benefits of staying the same, the costs of staying the same, the costs of changing, and the benefits of changing. Some worksheets use only two columns, pros and cons of changing, which matches the two factors found in later research.

How is DBT pros and cons different from a decisional balance?

DBT pros and cons is a distress tolerance skill for crisis urges. It compares acting on an urge with resisting it, looks at short and long term consequences, and is written ahead of time while calm so it can be reread in the moment. The person has usually already decided they want to resist.

Can I use a decisional balance with teenagers?

Yes, especially for neutral choices such as schools, activities or jobs. For risky behaviors where the counselor hopes for change, it is usually better to explore the teen's own goals and reasons than to list the benefits of the risky behavior in detail. Lead with autonomy and avoid lecturing.

What stage of change is decisional balance best for?

As an assessment, it is informative at any stage. As an exercise, it tends to help most when someone is neutral about a personal decision or has already moved into preparation, action or maintenance. For people in contemplation who are ambivalent about a change, MI evocation is usually the better choice.

Can I print the free decisional balance worksheet for clients?

Yes. The free PDF is an original Lotus & Tulip layout you can print for your own use and for your own clients, students or groups. Please link to this page instead of re-uploading the file.

Relapse Prevention WorksheetsHoliday 20% off: about $9.20, was $12 (EUR 10)
Buy on Etsy