Holiday sale: 20% off our printables on Etsy, Nov 16 to Dec 2. Shop the sale

School counselors · Updated 2026-11-11

School Counselor Performance Appraisal: How to Use the ASCA Fifth Edition Appraisal (0 to 3 Scale, Artifacts for Every Item, Filled Example, Free Printable)

Ready-made printable: Complete Small Group Counseling Bundle Holiday 20% off: about $29.44, was $37 (EUR 32) · instant digital download

Buy on Etsy
Title card: the ASCA school counselor performance appraisal, 0 to 3 scale and artifacts, with a free evidence planner
Complete Small Group Counseling Bundle: five eight session elementary group curricula (social skills, changing families, worry, anger and self esteem) to run as the small groups whose plans and data reports ASCA lists as appraisal artifacts for short-term counseling, each with a pre and post self check, a one page attendance and progress notes tracker, eight one page lesson plans, a teacher referral form, a parent letter with consent slip and a certificate, 125 printable US Letter pages (printable, not editable; not an appraisal kit or evidence portfolio: no appraisal form, rating guide or artifact list, no ASCA templates or data reports, no graphs, no ASCA standards on the lesson plans). See it on Etsy · Details.

Most school counselors are evaluated once a year, and many are evaluated on a form written for classroom teachers. The observation looks for a lesson, the rubric asks about grading and classroom management, and the work that fills most of a counselor's week (small groups, data conferences, referrals, the advisory council, the gap plan) has nowhere obvious to go. ASCA publishes its own answer to that problem: the School Counselor Performance Appraisal, a 14 page form that rates a counselor from 0 to 3 on the beliefs and behaviors of the profession and lists, item by item, the artifacts that can show them.

This guide explains exactly what is in ASCA's current appraisal, using only ASCA's own documents downloaded today: the appraisal itself, the ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment it is built on, the School Counseling Program Assessment, ASCA's 2026 position statement "The School Counselor and Annual Performance Appraisal," the Templates and Resources page and the "Changes in the ASCA National Model Fifth Edition" document. It covers what the form rates and what it does not, the 0 to 3 scale and what ASCA does and does not define, all 30 rated items with the artifacts ASCA suggests, which of your ordinary National Model documents count as evidence for the most items, how to use the form with a principal who evaluates you on a teacher instrument, a ten step method, a full worked example for one fictional school, scenarios, mistakes and a plain list of what ASCA's documents do not say.

At the end is a free three page printable: an appraisal evidence planner for all 30 items (self rating, administrator rating and the artifact you will bring), the same planner filled in for a fictional elementary school, and an appraisal conversation and growth plan sheet.

Jump to the free appraisal evidence planner, filled example and conversation sheet

This is educational information for school counselors, not official ASCA guidance and not legal or human resources advice. ASCA National Model, RAMP and ACSC are registered trademarks of the American School Counselor Association, and Lotus & Tulip is not affiliated with or endorsed by ASCA. Everything on this page was checked against ASCA's own public documents and pages, downloaded from schoolcounselor.org on November 11, 2026: the School Counselor Performance Appraisal (14 page PDF), the "All Assessments" download, the ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment (7 page PDF), the School Counseling Program Assessment (fifth edition), the Templates and Resources page, ASCA's collected position statements (including "The School Counselor and Annual Performance Appraisal," revised 2026), "Changes in the ASCA National Model Fifth Edition" and the RAMP Scoring Rubric, Fifth Edition. One quote is from our copy of the free fifth edition National Model download, which ASCA now offers through a request form we did not submit; we say so where it appears. Quotes are exact, except that ASCA's curly apostrophes are shown as straight ones, range dashes as hyphens, and registered trademark symbols and in-text citations are left out. Anything we could not confirm is marked as such. Your district's evaluation rules, contract and state law always come first.

Want strong evidence for "Provides short-term counseling in small-group and individual settings"? ASCA's artifacts for that item include small-group plans and data reports, and the easiest groups to document are the ones you had time to plan and run well. The Complete Small Group Counseling Bundle (now about $29.44 on Etsy, was $37) is five eight session elementary group curricula for grades 2 to 5 (social skills, changing families, worry, anger and self regulation, and self esteem) in five PDFs, 125 US Letter pages. Each group has eight one page lesson plans with matching student pages, a pre and post self check, a one page "Attendance and progress notes" tracker with a pre and post table, a teacher referral form, a parent letter with consent slip, group agreements and a certificate, with a use license for your own school. To be clear about what is not in it: it is not an appraisal kit or an evidence portfolio. There is no performance appraisal form, rating guide, artifact list or growth plan, no ASCA templates or Small-Group Plan and Data Report, no graphs or spreadsheets, the lesson plans do not name ASCA behavior standards, the self checks are not mapped to ASCA standards, there are no academic, reading, math or attendance groups, and the pages are printable, not editable. You would still complete ASCA's own plans, run the groups and collect your own data.

See the 5 group bundle on Etsy

The short answer

What the School Counselor Performance Appraisal is

The fifth edition ASCA National Model has four components: Define, Manage, Deliver and Assess. Assess has two parts in ASCA's diamond graphic: "Program Assessment" and "School Counselor Assessment and Appraisal." The second part is where the performance appraisal lives, next to the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment.

ASCA's Templates and Resources page lists three downloads under the heading Assessments and introduces them with one sentence: "School counselors regularly assess their own skills and their program to determine its effectiveness in enhancing access, life-readiness and academic success for each and every student. The following three assessments are available for download." The three are the School Counseling Program Assessment, the ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment and the School Counselor Performance Appraisal.

In our copy of the fifth edition National Model framework (ASCA's free download, which ASCA now offers through a request form), a two row table titled "School Counselor Assessment and Appraisal" sets the two counselor level tools side by side:

Purpose (ASCA's words)Description (ASCA's words)How it promotes success for each and every student (ASCA's words)
"Self-assess your own mindsets and behaviors and formulate an appropriate professional development plan""The ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment is used to self-assess the school counselor's knowledge, attitudes and skills needed to implement a school counseling program""Continued professional development promotes increased school counseling expertise, leading to improved student outcomes."
"Gain feedback on your performance as a school counselor""The ASCA School Counselor Performance Appraisal provides a guide for performance evaluation measured by expectations that are specific to the school counseling profession.""Provides an opportunity for the school counselor to share artifacts of activities implemented to improve student achievement and create systematic change for each and every student."

Two phrases in that table explain the whole tool. It is "a guide for performance evaluation," not a mandated instrument. And its value for the counselor is "an opportunity ... to share artifacts." The form is designed around evidence: almost every responsibility ends with a list headed "Artifacts may include."

The three ASCA assessments compared

Counselors often mix these up, and the program assessment guide on this site has the same table from the program side. They answer three different questions.

School Counseling Program AssessmentProfessional Standards & Competencies AssessmentSchool Counselor Performance Appraisal
What it looks atThe program: 25 Deliver, Manage and Assess benchmarksYou: the mindsets and behaviors of a school counselorYou: the same mindsets and behaviors, rated by an evaluator
Who completes itThe counseling team (ASCA does not say who)You, as a self-assessmentAn evaluator (the form has a line labeled "Evaluator")
Response formatYes box and comments for each benchmarkA blank line before each item (ASCA prints no scale)A rating from 0 to 3 for each of 30 items, plus four comment boxes
EvidenceNone listed on the formNone listed"Artifacts may include" lists under each of the 23 responsibilities
How oftenThe program assessment's own benchmarks expect the performance appraisal yearlyThe program assessment lists it as completedThe program assessment benchmark: "School Counseling Performance Appraisal is conducted annually."
Format todayWord document (.docx)PDF, 7 pagesFillable PDF, 14 pages

The program assessment ties the two counselor tools to the program in two benchmarks under Assess: "ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies assessment is completed." and "School Counseling Performance Appraisal is conducted annually." If you completed the program assessment and marked the second one not yet, this guide is the plan for turning it into a yes.

The Professional Standards & Competencies document also names the appraisal directly. Its first page says school and district administrators use it to "Guide the recruitment and selection of competent school counselors" and to "Develop or inform meaningful school counselor performance appraisal." So the standards are the content, the self-assessment is your private check against them, and the appraisal is the evaluator's version of the same check.

The form, page by page

We downloaded the School Counselor Performance Appraisal twice today: from the link on the Templates and Resources page and inside the "All Assessments" zip. Both files are byte for byte identical. The link on the page ends in ".docx", but the file it serves is a 14 page US Letter PDF with fillable fields, not a Word document. The PDF's internal creation date is July 2, 2025. ASCA's "Changes in the ASCA National Model Fifth Edition" lists one change for the "School Counselor Performance Appraisal Template": "Language alignment," described as "Updated to align with language from the fifth edition."

Three practical details we noticed in the file itself, which ASCA does not mention:

The form also carries a few small typing slips in ASCA's own text, for example "school counsleing program" in Direct and Indirect Student Services item 1e and "accessment" in Planning and Assessment item 4a. They do not change the meaning, but if you paste items into a district crosswalk, fix the spelling and say the wording is adapted.

The 0 to 3 scale: what ASCA defines and what it leaves to you

The only scale guidance on the form is one line under the header: "0=Unsatisfactory, 1=Developing, 2=Proficient, 3=Distinguished." The appraisal has no rubric, no level descriptors, no examples of a 2 versus a 3, no rule for how many indicators must be met, and no instruction on combining ratings. We checked every page, the Templates and Resources page, the position statement and the Professional Standards & Competencies document; none of them defines the levels.

That leaves a real risk: two evaluators can read "Proficient" very differently, and a principal used to a teacher rubric may treat 3 as normal and 2 as a warning, or 2 as normal and 3 as nearly impossible. Agree on working definitions before anyone rates anything. The definitions below are ours, not ASCA's. They are written to fit the way the form is built (indicators plus artifacts) and you can change them, but write down whatever you agree.

RatingASCA's labelA working definition you could agree on (ours, not ASCA's)What the evidence usually looks like
0UnsatisfactoryThe behavior is not happening, or happens in a way that conflicts with the item (for example, acting against the ethical standards).No artifact exists, or the artifact shows the opposite.
1DevelopingThe behavior has started but is partial, inconsistent or planned rather than done. Many new counselors and new programs are honestly here on several items.A draft, a plan, or one example; most indicators not yet shown.
2ProficientThe behavior is in place and consistent this year, and most indicators are shown. This is the expected level for an experienced counselor.A completed artifact for this year, used as intended (shared, signed, presented or acted on).
3DistinguishedProficient, plus the behavior shows results or reaches beyond your own caseload: data showing impact, a changed policy or practice, training others, or leadership outside the school.Completed artifacts plus results data, or evidence that others changed what they do because of your work.

A few rules that make the ratings fairer, all ours:

How the appraisal follows the Professional Standards & Competencies

The 30 rated items follow the ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies in the same order. The appraisal does not print the codes, so we have added them. The item titles are rewritten from the competencies' "Apply," "Use" and "Provide" into "Demonstrates," "Applies" and "Provides," and most lettered lists match. By our count the self-assessment has a few more competencies under B-PF 1 (six, against four indicators on the appraisal), B-PF 2 (nine against eight) and B-PF 5 (five against four).

Appraisal sectionItems ratedMatching competenciesIndicators listed (our count)Artifacts listed (our count)
Professional Beliefs: Mindsets7M 1 to M 7None (the statements are the items)None
Behaviors: Professional Foundation9B-PF 1 to B-PF 95437
Behaviors: Direct and Indirect Student Services6B-SS 1 to B-SS 63324
Behavior: Planning and Assessment8B-PA 1 to B-PA 84929
Total3013690

This matters in practice. If you complete the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment in the fall, you have already done a first, private pass at the appraisal. Item B-PF 4 even lists that self-assessment as an artifact: "Completed ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies self-assessment with written plans for own professional growth." And the last appraisal item, B-PA 8, lists as an artifact a "Completed performance appraisal aligned with the ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies."

The belief statements are worded slightly differently in the two documents. The self-assessment says "School counselors believe:" followed by statements such as "Each and every student deserves access to a school counseling program." The appraisal turns each into an observable behavior: "Demonstrates belief that each and every student should have access to the school counseling program." The appraisal's version is the one being rated, so evidence has to show the belief in action, not just state it.

Professional Beliefs: the seven mindsets

The first page asks the evaluator to rate seven statements, each beginning "Demonstrates belief that." ASCA lists no artifacts for them. Beliefs are hard to rate from a document, which is exactly why they are worth preparing for. The useful question for each one is: what did I do this year that someone who did not hold this belief would not have done?

CodeItem (exact)Evidence that shows the belief in action (our suggestions)
M 1"Demonstrates belief that each and every student can learn and succeed"A gap plan aimed at students who are furthest behind; goals with real targets, not "maintain"; follow up with students who did not improve.
M 2"Demonstrates belief that each and every student should have access and opportunity to a high-quality education"Data on who gets into advanced courses, enrichment or interventions, and what you did about a gap; removing a barrier such as transportation or language.
M 3"Demonstrates belief that each and every student should graduate from high school prepared for postsecondary opportunities"Career lessons in every grade (yes, elementary too), college and career events, postsecondary plans completed by all students, not only those who ask.
M 4"Demonstrates belief that each and every student should have access to the school counseling program"A delivery plan that reaches every grade; how students and families can request you; materials in families' home languages.
M 5"Demonstrates belief that effective school counseling programs are a collaborative process involving school counselors and education partners, such as families, staff, administrators, decision-makers, and any other school or community organizations/individuals"Advisory council membership and minutes; teacher data meetings; family conferences; a partner list.
M 6"Demonstrates belief that school counselors are leaders in the school, district, state and nation"Committee roles, presentations to staff, the school improvement team, association work.
M 7"Demonstrates belief that school counseling programs promote and enhance student academic, career and social/emotional development"A delivery plan and data reports that cover all three domains, with results.

A tip that ASCA's own artifact list supports: Planning and Assessment item 1 lists "Belief statements aligned with mindsets from ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies" as an artifact. A one page personal beliefs statement, written once and revised each August, gives the evaluator something concrete to read for all seven beliefs.

Professional Foundation: nine items and the artifacts ASCA lists

For each item below, the title is ASCA's exact wording. The middle column summarizes ASCA's "Artifacts may include" list for that item (quoted where marked). The right column is our advice on which artifact makes the strongest case, because a list of possible artifacts is not the same as knowing which one to bring.

CodeItem (exact)ASCA's artifactsStrongest evidence to bring (ours)
B-PF 1"Demonstrates a working knowledge of developmental, learning, counseling and education theories"Agendas for PD you led on theories; counselor-made information sheets or infographics (ASCA's examples include "how to choose a career path" and how children process grief); the ASCA Student Standards delivery plan and data report; the achievement gap plan and data report.One handout you wrote for teachers or families, plus the gap plan, with a sentence on which theory or MTSS tier shaped the intervention (indicator d: "Uses principles of a multitiered system of supports").
B-PF 2"Demonstrates understanding of educational systems, legal issues, policies, research and educational trends"Evidence of advocacy at district, state or national level; family or teacher workshop materials on the counselor's role; a presentation on how the program aligns with the school vision or mission; "Minutes from school counseling advisory committee meetings"; "List of citations from research used to inform decision and program development."The fall advisory council minutes where you presented alignment with the mission, plus a short reference list for this year's curricula.
B-PF 3"Applies legal and ethical principles of the school counseling profession"A posted ethical standard in the office (ASCA's example: a "limits of confidentiality statement"); weekly calendars documenting critical interactions; certificates from law and ethics PD.A photo of the posted confidentiality statement, an ethics PD certificate from this year, and a one line note of how you used an ethical decision-making model (without any student detail).
B-PF 4"Applies school counseling professional standards and competencies"Membership in state and national school counselor organizations; the "Completed ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies self-assessment with written plans for own professional growth"; names and contacts of people you consult for supervision.The completed self-assessment with a dated professional development plan. Indicator d asks for "a yearly professional development plan."
B-PF 5"Uses ASCA Student Standards: Mindsets & Behaviors for Student Success to inform the implementation of the school counseling program"Completed ASCA Student Standards delivery plan; completed achievement gap plan and data report; completed small-group session plans and data report; completed lesson plans.The delivery plan, with the standards on it traced to one lesson plan and one small-group plan. Indicator a asks that standards address "student needs demonstrated in data."
B-PF 6"Demonstrates understanding of the impact of cultural, social and environmental influences on student success and opportunities"Certificates from PD on cultural, social or environmental influences; lesson plans or materials from sessions you led "designed to build culturally sustaining behaviors in others"; an annual professional growth plan.A change you made because of what you learned about students' backgrounds (translated materials, changed meeting times, a referral pathway), plus the PD certificate. Remember the rating field for this item is missing from the fillable PDF.
B-PF 7"Demonstrates leadership through the development and implementation of the school counseling program"Leadership roles on school, district or community committees; participation in professional associations; completed achievement gap plan and data report; annual calendar; advisory council agendas and minutes; ACSC certification; RAMP certification.The annual calendar and the gap plan together show you lead the program, not just deliver it. Indicator e (using program assessment results to redesign the program) pairs well with your program assessment action plan.
B-PF 8"Demonstrates advocacy in the school counseling program"Presentations to the school board or oversight bodies; presentations to education partners; "Reports showing how school counselor's time could be spent more effectively for student success (complete use-of-time calculator)"; association advocacy events; infographics based on data reports.The use-of-time calculator summary you brought to the administrator conference, and what you asked for (indicators d and e: rationale for appropriate activities and for discontinuing inappropriate ones).
B-PF 9"Creates systemic change through the implementation of the school counseling program"Reports showing change in achievement or contributing-factors data; reports showing change in course enrollment or access; reports showing postsecondary success "linked to National Student Clearinghouse data."One policy, schedule or practice that changed because of your data, with the before and after numbers. Elementary counselors: access changes (bus routes, family language, group scheduling) count.

Direct and Indirect Student Services: six items

CodeItem (exact)ASCA's artifactsStrongest evidence to bring (ours)
B-SS 1"Designs and implements instruction aligned to ASCA Mindsets & Behaviors for Student Success in classroom, large-group, small-group and individual settings"Completed ASCA Student Standards delivery plan and data report; achievement gap plan and data report; small-group plans and data reports; lesson plans and data reports; annual calendar.One lesson plan and data report with pre and post results. Indicator h: "Analyzes data from lessons and activities to determine impact on student access and life-readiness."
B-SS 2"Provides appraisal and advisement in classroom, large-group, small-group and individual settings"Completed graduation plans; completed postsecondary plans; career interest inventories with lesson plans "showing appraisal & advisement activities"; strengths inventories with such lesson plans; field trips to community organizations, businesses and postsecondary institutions.Secondary: graduation and postsecondary plans completion rates. Elementary: a strengths or interest inventory lesson with the follow up advisement. Many elementary counselors are honestly a 1 or 2 here; plan one inventory lesson per grade band.
B-SS 3"Provides short-term counseling in small-group and individual settings"Achievement gap plan and data report; small-group plans and data reports; presentations on trauma-informed practices; a crisis response "pack" or bag/box; membership on district crisis response teams.A small-group plan and data report with results, plus a count (not names) of individual short-term counseling. Indicator d asks you to explain why "providing long-term therapy is inappropriate."
B-SS 4"Makes referrals to appropriate school and community resources""List of school and community referral sources"; "School-counselor-developed school counseling brochure."The referral list dated this year, with how often you update it, and the brochure in every language your families need.
B-SS 5"Consults to support student achievement and success"Materials from trainings or workshops you led; materials for education partners (ASCA's examples: "why school attendance matters, how to help with homework, why mentoring works"); a schedule of family programs; membership on the school leadership or data team.The family program schedule and one workshop handout. Indicator d asks for in-service training or workshops you facilitate.
B-SS 6"Collaborates with education partners, such as families, staff, administrators, decision-makers, and any other school or community organizations/individuals, for student achievement and success"A list of groups that partner with the program; a list of committee involvement; "Agenda and minutes from school counselor advisory meetings."The partner list and both advisory council agendas and minutes. Indicator d (supervising interns) only applies if you have one; agree how to handle it.

Planning and Assessment: eight items

CodeItem (exact)ASCA's artifactsStrongest evidence to bring (ours)
B-PA 1"Articulates how the school counseling program aligns with school and district vision and mission statement""Belief statements aligned with mindsets from ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies"; "Statement of how the school counseling program aligns with the school and/or district vision and mission statements."Your personal beliefs statement and the alignment statement from the first-semester advisory council template (the same 100 word statement RAMP item 3.5 asks for).
B-PA 2"Identifies achievement gaps and factors contributing to those gaps"Disaggregated achievement data reports showing gaps; disaggregated contributing-factors reports; goals addressing gaps; "Completed school counseling data priorities"; annual and completed achievement gap plan and data report.The data priorities template with the disaggregated table that led to your gap plan.
B-PA 3"Develops achievement gap plan(s) based on student data annually"Completed data priorities; completed gap plan(s) and data report(s) "including baseline and target data including goals, contributing-factors data and appropriate standards from the ASCA Student Standards"; the contributing-factors list; selected curricula; presentations about the plan; documentation of the data and feedback used to refine it.This year's gap plan and data report, and one example of a mid-year adjustment (indicator n: "Uses student data and feedback ... to monitor and refine"). With 14 indicators, this is the most detailed item on the form.
B-PA 4"Assesses and reports program impact to the school community""Presentation materials with data from school counseling activities"; completed data priorities; completed gap plan(s) and data report(s).The slides or handout from the spring advisory council or a staff meeting where you shared results in totals.
B-PA 5"Uses time appropriately according to national recommendations and student/school data""Use-of-time calculator completed with time percentages in direct and indirect student services (80% or more) and program planning and school support (20% or less)"; "Completed annual administrator conference and meeting notes"; "Annual and weekly calendars."The calculator summary and the conference notes. This artifact names the target directly, so be ready to discuss a result under 80 percent honestly.
B-PA 6"Establishes agreement about the school counseling program with the administrator in charge of the school counseling program"One artifact only: "Completed annual administrator conference signed by the administrator in charge of the school counseling program and the school counselor."The signed annual administrator conference template. If it is not signed, this item is hard to rate above 1.
B-PA 7"Establishes and convenes an advisory council for the school counseling program"A list of representatives with their positions; agendas; minutes; presentation materials (handouts, infographics, slides).Membership list, both agendas and both sets of minutes, with the feedback you acted on (indicator f).
B-PA 8"Uses appropriate school counselor performance appraisal process""Completed performance appraisal aligned with the ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies"; artifacts showing completion or progress on National Model components; ACSC application and score results; RAMP application and score results.Last year's appraisal and a crosswalk you wrote showing where counseling work fits the district's form (indicator b: "Explains how school counseling activities fit within categories of a performance appraisal instrument").

B-PA 8 is the item where the appraisal rates you on the appraisal process itself. Its first indicator is "Explains and advocates for appropriate school counselor performance appraisal process based on school counselor standards and implementation of the school counseling program." In other words, ASCA counts it as part of the job for you to bring this form and explain it.

One evidence folder, many items: which documents count the most

Read the 90 artifact examples together and a pattern appears: most of them are documents a National Model program produces anyway. You do not need a separate appraisal portfolio. You need this year's ordinary documents, filed so you can find them. The table counts, by our reading, how many of the 23 responsibilities list each document (or a close variant) as an artifact.

Document you already makeListed as an artifact underNumber of items
Achievement gap plan and data reportB-PF 1, B-PF 5, B-PF 7, B-SS 1, B-SS 3, B-PA 2, B-PA 3, B-PA 48
Advisory council agendas and minutes (and members list)B-PF 2, B-PF 7, B-SS 6, B-PA 74
Lesson plans (and lesson data reports)B-PF 5, B-PF 6, B-SS 1, B-SS 24
Small-group plans and data reportsB-PF 5, B-SS 1, B-SS 33
ASCA Student Standards delivery planB-PF 1, B-PF 5, B-SS 13
School counseling data prioritiesB-PA 2, B-PA 3, B-PA 43
Annual calendarB-PF 7, B-SS 1, B-PA 53
Professional association membership or participationB-PF 4, B-PF 7, B-PF 83
Use-of-time calculatorB-PF 8, B-PA 52
Annual administrator conferenceB-PA 5, B-PA 62
Professional development certificatesB-PF 3, B-PF 62
ACSC and RAMPB-PF 7, B-PA 82
Professional Standards & Competencies self-assessmentB-PF 4 (and, as the basis of the appraisal, B-PA 8)1 to 2
Weekly calendarsB-PF 3, B-PA 52

Two conclusions follow. First, the achievement gap plan and data report is the single most valuable document for your appraisal, not only for RAMP. Second, a counselor who completes the core fifth edition templates (data priorities, gap plan, delivery plan, lesson and small-group plans with data reports, calendars, use of time, the administrator conference and two advisory council meetings) already has artifacts for most of the form. The items that usually need something extra are the mindsets, B-PF 3 (ethics), B-PF 6 (culture), B-SS 2 (appraisal and advisement), B-SS 4 (referrals) and B-SS 5 (consultation).

Keep the folder free of student names. The appraisal is a personnel document that other people will read and keep. Bring data reports in totals, and leave session notes, referral forms and anything with a student's name out of it. ASCA's own artifact for ethics asks for calendars "regarding documentation of critical interactions with students," which you can show as a count or a redacted page, not a case file.

Using the appraisal with your administrator

ASCA's position statement "The School Counselor and Annual Performance Appraisal" (adopted 1978, revised 2026) is the clearest statement of what ASCA expects. Its position: "The annual performance appraisal of school counselors should accurately reflect the unique professional training and practices of school counselors working within a pre-K-12 school counseling program." It continues that appraisals "should be aligned to the role and responsibilities of the school counselors as articulated by ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies, the ASCA Ethical Standards for School Counselors, the school counseling program assessment and the school counselor performance appraisal from the ASCA National Model."

The rationale names the problem plainly: "Because many administrators have not received training on the ASCA National Model and how to appraise school counselor performance, part of school counselor advocacy includes informing school administrators and other educational partners about the role of the school counselor and that of the school counseling program." It also links the appraisal to a document you may already complete: "The annual administrator conference, as described in the ASCA National Model, is an essential practice to support the school counselor appraisal process."

Under "The School Counselor's Role," the statement lists four things the counselor does:

Read together with the form, that gives a simple yearly cycle. The dates are ours; ASCA does not set them.

When (suggested)What happensWhat you bring
AugustAnnual administrator conference. Agree on use of time, goals and plans, and agree how the appraisal will work this year: which form, who rates, the working definitions of 0 to 3, and the dates below.Last year's appraisal and growth goals, the use-of-time summary, a copy of ASCA's appraisal.
SeptemberSelf-assessment. Complete the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment and a first self rating on the appraisal. Pick two or three growth goals.Your professional development plan (B-PF 4 artifact).
October to DecemberCollect artifacts as they are produced: fall council minutes, data priorities, gap plan, lesson plans.Nothing; just file them.
JanuaryMid-year check. A short meeting on the growth goals and any item heading for a 1.Mid-year data (gap plan progress, groups finished).
April to MaySpring advisory council and data reports. Share results in totals.Presentation materials (B-PA 4 artifact).
May or JuneEnd-of-year appraisal meeting. Compare self and administrator ratings item by item, agree final ratings and comments, set next year's goals.The evidence planner and the artifact folder.

When your district evaluates you on a teacher form

This is the most common situation and the position statement was written for it. ASCA's appraisal does not say it replaces a district instrument, and in most districts you cannot simply swap forms: the evaluation tool is set by district policy, sometimes by state law, and often by a bargaining agreement. What you can usually do is use ASCA's appraisal alongside the official form, as evidence and as the conversation.

Some states publish their own school counselor evaluation models. Our school counselor evaluation crosswalk guide compares Ohio's OSCES, Pennsylvania's school counselor framework, North Carolina's counseling standards and Texas guidance with their teacher instruments, and includes a free crosswalk worksheet. Always check your state department of education and your district policy first.

What to say: short scripts

Proposing it at the August conference: "Our district form was written for classroom teachers. ASCA publishes a performance appraisal built on the school counselor professional standards, with a list of artifacts for each item. Would you be willing to use it alongside the district form this year, so we can agree on what good work looks like for my role? I will bring the evidence and a crosswalk to the district domains."

Agreeing the scale: "ASCA only labels the levels, so can we agree now that 2, Proficient, means the work is in place and done well this year, and 3 means there is evidence of results or impact beyond my own caseload?"

When your ratings differ: "I rated myself a 2 on this one and you rated a 3. Can you tell me what you saw? I would like to understand what made it distinguished so I can keep doing it."

When a rating is low and fair: "That is a fair 1. Use of time is below 80 percent mostly because of testing coordination. Can we make moving part of it a goal for next year, and can I bring two new calculator weeks to the August conference?"

When a rating is low and you disagree: "I understand why it looks that way from the outside. Here is the artifact for this item. Would you be willing to look at it and reconsider, or note in the comments that we discussed it?" Then follow your district's process for written responses if you still disagree.

How to complete the ASCA performance appraisal, step by step

  1. Download the current form and the standards. Get the School Counselor Performance Appraisal and the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment from ASCA's Templates and Resources page, and check your district's official evaluation rules.
  2. Agree the process at the administrator conference. Decide with your administrator which form is the form of record, how ASCA's appraisal will be used, who rates, and the dates for the self rating, mid-year check and final meeting.
  3. Agree what 0 to 3 means. Write down a working definition of each level, since ASCA gives only the labels, and agree not to average the ratings.
  4. Self-assess first. Complete the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment and a first self rating on all 30 appraisal items, honestly, in September.
  5. Choose two or three growth goals. Pick the items where a realistic change this year matters most for students, and write what you will do, by when, and what artifact will show it.
  6. Name one artifact per item. For each of the 23 responsibilities, choose the single strongest artifact from ASCA's list or your own work. For the seven beliefs, note what you did that shows each one.
  7. File artifacts as you go. Keep one folder with this year's templates, data reports, calendars, minutes and certificates, in totals, without student names.
  8. Hold a mid-year check. Meet briefly on the growth goals and any item that looks like a 1, while there is still time to change it.
  9. Rate, compare and discuss. Before the final meeting, update your self ratings. In the meeting, compare item by item, discuss every difference, and record agreed ratings and comments in the four comment boxes.
  10. Set next year's goals and keep a copy. Turn the lowest agreed ratings into next year's growth goals, add them to the August conference agenda, and keep a copy of the completed appraisal (it is itself an artifact for B-PA 8).

A worked example: Maple Hollow Elementary, 2028 to 2029 (fictional)

Maple Hollow Elementary is a fictional public elementary school with kindergarten to grade 5, 426 students and one school counselor, J. Rivera. The principal, A. Brooks, is the administrator in charge of the school counseling program. Readers of our other guides have followed the school's 2028 to 2029 school year, its RAMP data collection year: the annual administrator conference on Thursday, August 24, 2028, the first-semester advisory council on Tuesday, October 17, 2028, the Reading Strong achievement gap plan for grade 4 students with a 1 in reading, the Plan It, Pack It grade 4 classroom lesson, the Cool and Ready grade 5 small group, the second-semester advisory council on Thursday, April 26, 2029, and the data report graphs finished on Tuesday, June 12, 2029.

When Rivera completed the program assessment in June 2028, she marked "School Counseling Performance Appraisal is conducted annually" as not yet, because the district evaluates counselors on its teacher evaluation form. Her action was to ask Brooks whether ASCA's appraisal could be used alongside it.

August: agreeing the process

At the August 24, 2028 conference, Brooks agreed. The district form stays the form of record. ASCA's appraisal becomes the evidence guide and the agenda for three meetings: Rivera's self rating by Thursday, September 14, 2028, a 20 minute mid-year check on Thursday, January 25, 2029, and the end-of-year appraisal meeting on Wednesday, June 13, 2029, the day after the graphs are finished. They wrote the working definitions of 0 to 3 from this guide into the conference notes, agreed not to average, and agreed that B-SS 6 indicator d (supervising interns) would be marked "not applicable this year" in the comments because the school had no intern.

September: the self rating and three growth goals

Rivera completed the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment and a first self rating. She chose three growth goals, all from items she rated 1 or expected to struggle with:

January: the mid-year check

By January 25, 2029 the Reading Strong plan was under way, the bus route request for five students was with the district, and the referral list was updated. The brochure and the inventory lesson had not started. Brooks suggested moving the inventory lesson to the following year rather than squeezing it into testing season, and Rivera agreed to note that honestly in June.

June: the ratings

Rivera updated her self ratings the week before the meeting. Brooks rated independently from the evidence planner and the folder. Here are all 30 items as rated on June 13, 2029.

CodeItem (short)Rivera's self ratingBrooks's ratingMain artifact
M 1Every student can learn and succeed33Reading Strong gap plan for the 15 lowest grade 4 readers
M 2Access to a high-quality education22Spanish reading comments; bus route request
M 3Graduate prepared for postsecondary22Career lessons in grades 3 to 5 on the delivery plan
M 4Access to the school counseling program33Delivery plan: lessons in every grade, K to 5
M 5Programs are collaborative33Council minutes Oct 17 and Apr 26; teacher data meetings
M 6School counselors are leaders12School improvement team; staff data presentation
M 7Academic, career, social/emotional development22Delivery plan and data reports in all three domains
B-PF 1Theories (incl. MTSS)22Gap plan (Tier 2); family handout on reading at home
B-PF 2Systems, policy, research, trends22Oct 17 council minutes (mission alignment)
B-PF 3Legal and ethical principles33Posted confidentiality statement; ethics PD certificate
B-PF 4Professional standards and competencies22PS&C self-assessment and PD plan, Sept 2028
B-PF 5Uses the ASCA Student Standards33Delivery plan, gap, lesson and small-group plans
B-PF 6Cultural, social, environmental influences22Spanish reports and letters; PD certificate
B-PF 7Leadership22Annual calendar; gap plan; council agendas
B-PF 8Advocacy22Use-of-time summary; testing coordination request
B-PF 9Systemic change23Bus route changed Feb 5, 2029; absences 63* to 34
B-SS 1Instruction33Plan It, Pack It lesson plan and data report
B-SS 2Appraisal and advisement11None yet: grade 5 inventory lesson planned
B-SS 3Short-term counseling33Cool and Ready small-group plan and data report
B-SS 4Referrals22Referral list updated Sept 2028; brochure English only
B-SS 5Consultation32Teacher data meetings; no family workshop this year
B-SS 6Collaboration33Partner list; both council agendas and minutes
B-PA 1Vision and mission alignment33Beliefs statement; alignment statement for Oct 17
B-PA 2Identifies gaps33Data priorities with disaggregated reading data
B-PA 3Achievement gap plan annually33Gap plan and data report; mid-year adjustment
B-PA 4Assesses and reports impact22Apr 26 council handout, results in totals
B-PA 5Use of time11Calculators 76.1% (2027-28); conference notes
B-PA 6Agreement with the administrator33Conference template signed Aug 24, 2028
B-PA 7Advisory council33Members list, two agendas, two sets of minutes
B-PA 8Appraisal process22This appraisal; crosswalk to the district form

The counts: Brooks rated 14 items Distinguished, 14 Proficient and 2 Developing, and none Unsatisfactory. Rivera rated herself 14 Distinguished, 13 Proficient and 3 Developing. Neither of them averaged the numbers.

The three differences

The comments

Brooks wrote the four "Observations and comments" boxes from the meeting. The Planning and Assessment box read: "Achievement gap plan built on disaggregated reading data, adjusted at mid-year, results shared with the council in totals. Conference template signed in August. Use of time remains below 80 percent, mainly testing coordination; district decision pending. Agreed 2029-30 goal: two calculator weeks, results at the August conference." The Direct and Indirect Student Services box noted that B-SS 6 indicator d was not applicable, and that the B-SS 2 rating reflects work planned but not delivered.

Next year's goals

The same use-of-time action appears in Rivera's RAMP reflection for item 7.2, written in August 2029. Her appraisal, program assessment, administrator conference and RAMP reflections now tell one consistent story, which is the point of the National Model's Assess component.

Planning a worry or test anxiety group for next year's B-SS 3 evidence? A group like Cool and Ready gives you a small-group plan and data report, which ASCA lists as an artifact for short-term counseling, instruction and the Student Standards items, and a ready curriculum frees your time for the plan and the data. The Calm and Brave Worry Group curriculum (now about $11.04 on Etsy, was $14) is an eight session anxiety small group for grades 2 to 5 in one 25 page US Letter PDF: what is worry, body clues, calm body tools, catch it and check it, brave self talk, what I can control, facing fears step by step, and a closing "My calm and brave toolkit" session. It includes a pre and post self check with faces, an "Attendance and progress notes" page with a pre and post table, eight one page lesson plans, a teacher referral form, a parent letter with consent slip, group agreements, matching student pages and a certificate. It teaches coping skills and is not a diagnostic or treatment program. Not included: any appraisal form, rating guide, artifact list or evidence portfolio, any ASCA template (it is not a Small-Group Plan and Data Report), graphs or a data spreadsheet, ASCA behavior standards on the lesson plans, learning objectives, knowledge items or answer keys, achievement data, test taking content, and editable files. Its face scale self check is not ASCA's four point agree scale, so you would write your own items for the data report.

See the worry group curriculum on Etsy

The appraisal and RAMP

The performance appraisal is not part of the RAMP application. We searched all 82 items of the RAMP Scoring Rubric, Fifth Edition (re-downloaded today and identical to the copy we checked this morning) and found no item that asks for the appraisal or the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment. The rubric mentions the competencies once, in its integrity rules: "your school counselors must agree to abide by the ASCA Ethical Standards for School Counselors and ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies."

The connection runs the other way. The appraisal lists "Recognized ASCA Model Program (RAMP) certification" as an artifact for leadership (B-PF 7) and "Recognized ASCA Model Program (RAMP) application and score results" as an artifact for B-PA 8, along with ACSC certification and score results. Almost every RAMP upload (the gap plan, lesson and small-group data reports, calendars, use of time, conference and council templates) is also appraisal evidence. If you are preparing a RAMP application, your appraisal folder is mostly built already, and the reverse is true too.

A checklist before the appraisal meeting

Six real world scenarios

"My principal has never seen this form." That is the situation the position statement describes. Bring it to the August conference, not to the end-of-year meeting, explain that it is ASCA's guide built on the professional standards, and offer to do the preparation: the self rating, the artifacts and the crosswalk.

"Our district requires the teacher evaluation form." Keep it as the form of record. Use ASCA's appraisal as your evidence guide and the agenda for the conversation, and write the crosswalk. B-PA 8 indicator b is literally about explaining how counseling activities fit another instrument.

"I am in my first year." Expect several 1s and say so in August. Choose two growth goals, not ten, and remember that 1 means developing, not failing. Your first year's artifacts (a first gap plan, a first council meeting) are the baseline for next year.

"I am a high school counselor." B-SS 2 (appraisal and advisement) is usually your strongest item: graduation and postsecondary plans are ASCA's first two artifacts. B-PA 5 is often the weakest because of scheduling and testing duties. Bring completion rates for plans and an honest use-of-time summary.

"I share the program with two other counselors." The appraisal rates each counselor, but many artifacts belong to the team. Say who led what. B-PA 6 indicator a expects the conference template completed "with other members of the school counseling staff," so shared artifacts are normal; just be clear about your part.

"My evaluator is not my principal." Some districts have a director of counseling or an assistant principal evaluate counselors. The form's header has a separate line for "Evaluator," and B-PA 6 is about "the administrator in charge of the school counseling program." Bring the person who signed your conference template into the conversation, or at least share the appraisal with them.

Common mistakes

  1. Bringing the appraisal to the final meeting for the first time. The process has to be agreed in August, or the form feels like an ambush.
  2. Treating 2 as a bad score. Proficient means the work is done well. Agree that out loud.
  3. Averaging 30 ratings into one number. ASCA prints no total, and an average hides the items that need attention.
  4. Bringing a box of everything. One strong artifact per item beats ten weak ones. Use the planner to name it.
  5. Bringing student names. The appraisal is a personnel record. Results go in totals.
  6. Rating beliefs without evidence. "Demonstrates belief" means something you did. Write one example for each of the seven.
  7. Skipping the self-assessment. The Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment is the same content, privately, and an artifact for B-PF 4. Our professional standards self-assessment guide shows how to rate all 140 competencies and turn them into a PD plan.
  8. Losing the item 6 rating on the fillable PDF. The cultural influences item has no typeable field in the current file.
  9. Leaving the administrator conference unsigned. B-PA 6 lists one artifact, and it is a signed administrator conference template. Get it signed in the fall.
  10. Setting goals and never mentioning them again. Growth goals belong on the mid-year check and the next August conference agenda.

What ASCA's documents do not tell you

We looked for each of these in the appraisal, the Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment, the program assessment, the Templates and Resources page, the position statement, the fifth edition changes document and the RAMP rubric on November 11, 2026, and did not find them:

Where this guide suggests working definitions, dates, scripts or a process, those are our suggestions, built from the form's structure and the position statement, and they are labeled as ours.

Free printable: appraisal evidence planner, filled example and conversation sheet

The free printable has three US Letter pages. Page 1 is a blank appraisal evidence planner: counselor, evaluator, school year and meeting dates at the top, then all 30 rated items of ASCA's appraisal in ASCA's order (shortened to fit and labeled with the Professional Standards & Competencies codes), each with a box for your self rating, a box for the evaluator's rating and a line for the one artifact you will bring. Page 2 is the same planner filled in for the fictional Maple Hollow Elementary appraisal on June 13, 2029, described above. Page 3 is an appraisal conversation and growth plan sheet: the scale with room to write your agreed working definitions, a before the meeting checklist, a table for every item where the two ratings differ (the evidence and the agreed rating), up to three growth goals (item, action, artifact that will show it, by when) and space for notes.

The printable is a planning tool. It does not replace ASCA's appraisal, which is the form you or your evaluator would actually rate on, and it does not replace your district's official evaluation.

Free school counselor performance appraisal evidence planner page 1: all 30 ASCA appraisal items with self rating, evaluator rating and artifact columns

Download the free appraisal evidence planner, example and conversation sheet (PDF, 3 pages)

Or download single pages: Page 1: blank evidence planner (PNG) · Page 2: filled example (PNG) · Page 3: conversation and growth plan sheet (PNG)

Free to print and use in your own school. Please link to this page rather than re-uploading the file. This is a planning tool, not an ASCA publication, and the item wording on it is shortened; use ASCA's School Counselor Performance Appraisal for the exact text. Keep student names off any copy you share.

Want next year's Tier 2 groups planned before the August conference? Growth goals and strong artifacts both start with a year you had time to plan. The Full Year Elementary Small Group Counseling Bundle (now about $45.08 on Etsy, was $56) is ten eight session elementary group curricula for kindergarten to grade 5 in five PDFs, 250 US Letter pages: social skills, girls friendship, worry, K to 2 feelings and coping, anger, bullying prevention, self esteem, growth mindset, changing families and grief. Every group has a pre and post self check (a read aloud picture version for K to 2), a parent letter with consent slip, group agreements, a group at a glance page, eight one page lesson plans with matching student pages, and a certificate of completion. Nine of the ten groups have a one page "Attendance and progress notes" tracker and a teacher referral form; the K to 2 Feelings Garden group has an attendance grid on its group at a glance page instead and does not include a teacher referral form. It is not an appraisal kit: it does not include a performance appraisal form, rating guide, artifact lists or growth plans, any ASCA template, small-group plans or data reports in ASCA's format, graphs or spreadsheets, ASCA behavior standards on the lesson plans or self checks, learning objectives, knowledge items with answer keys, achievement data, or editable files.

See the full year bundle on Etsy

Related resources

Sources: American School Counselor Association, School Counselor Performance Appraisal (14 page PDF, linked from the Templates and Resources page and included in the All Assessments download); ASCA, ASCA School Counselor Professional Standards & Competencies Assessment; ASCA, School Counseling Program Assessment (fifth edition); ASCA, "The School Counselor and Annual Performance Appraisal" position statement (adopted 1978, revised 2026), in ASCA's collected position statements; ASCA, Templates and Resources page; ASCA, "Changes in the ASCA National Model Fifth Edition"; ASCA, RAMP Scoring Rubric, Fifth Edition; all checked November 11, 2026. ASCA, "The ASCA National Model: A Framework for School Counseling Programs, Fifth Edition" (our copy of the free download). The working definitions, artifact advice, evidence counts, scripts, process, worked example and printable are original to Lotus & Tulip and are not ASCA publications.

FAQ

What is the ASCA School Counselor Performance Appraisal?

A 14 page form from the American School Counselor Association for evaluating a school counselor. It rates 30 items from 0 to 3: seven professional beliefs and 23 professional responsibilities in Professional Foundation, Direct and Indirect Student Services, and Planning and Assessment, with suggested artifacts for each responsibility. ASCA describes it as "a guide for performance evaluation measured by expectations that are specific to the school counseling profession."

What does the 0 to 3 scale mean?

The form says "0=Unsatisfactory, 1=Developing, 2=Proficient, 3=Distinguished" and gives no further descriptions. Agree working definitions with your evaluator before rating; a common approach is that 2 means the work is in place and done well this year and 3 adds evidence of results or impact beyond your own caseload.

How many items are on the ASCA performance appraisal?

30 rated items: 7 mindsets, 9 Professional Foundation items, 6 Direct and Indirect Student Services items and 8 Planning and Assessment items, matching the ASCA Professional Standards & Competencies M 1 to 7, B-PF 1 to 9, B-SS 1 to 6 and B-PA 1 to 8. By our count the responsibilities list 136 indicators and 90 example artifacts.

What artifacts should a school counselor bring to an evaluation?

One strong artifact per item, drawn from work you already do: the achievement gap plan and data report (listed under 8 of the 23 responsibilities), advisory council agendas and minutes, lesson and small-group plans with data reports, the delivery plan, data priorities, the annual calendar, the use-of-time calculator, the signed administrator conference template and your Professional Standards & Competencies self-assessment. Keep data in totals and leave student names out.

Can I use the ASCA appraisal if my district uses a teacher evaluation form?

Usually yes, alongside it. ASCA does not say its appraisal replaces a district instrument, and the official form is set by district policy. Ask your administrator at the annual administrator conference to use ASCA's appraisal as the evidence guide, and write a crosswalk from the district domains to the ASCA items. ASCA's 2026 position statement says appraisals should reflect counselors' training and the ASCA professional standards.

Is the performance appraisal part of RAMP?

No. No item in the RAMP Scoring Rubric, Fifth Edition asks for it. The appraisal lists RAMP and ACSC as artifacts instead, and most RAMP uploads also count as appraisal evidence. The program assessment does include the benchmark "School Counseling Performance Appraisal is conducted annually."

Complete Small Group Counseling BundleHoliday 20% off: about $29.44, was $37 (EUR 32)
Buy on Etsy